Category

2023 FALL PREMIER AUCTION

Auction closed on 12/2/2023. Final prices include buyers premium.

• Lot #7: 1902-11 W600 Sporting Life Cabinets John "Hans" Wagner (Pittsburgh Uniform) – PSA EX 5 (MK) -- Pop 1, One Higher!

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $50,000

  Final Price: $87,846

• Lot #8: 1911 M116 Sporting Life Hans Wagner (Pastel Background, Scarce '300 Subject' Back) – PSA NM-MT 8 (Pop 5, None Higher!)

  

  # Bids: 15

  Min Bid: $20,000

  Final Price: $82,864

• Lot #9: Exceptional Babe Ruth Autographed 1926-29 Exhibit Postcard – PSA GD 2, PSA/DNA 7 Auto.

  

  # Bids: 15

  Min Bid: $10,000

  Final Price: $60,667

• Lot #10: 1951 Bowman #253 Mickey Mantle Rookie – PSA EX-MT 6

  

  # Bids: 18

  Min Bid: $7,500

  Final Price: $45,510

• Lot #11: 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle – PSA VG 3

  

  # Bids: 13

  Min Bid: $10,000

  Final Price: $50,137

• Lot #12: 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle – PSA VG-EX 4

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $25,000

  Final Price: $70,745

• Lot #13: 1952 Topps #311 Mickey Mantle – PSA EX-MT 6

  

  # Bids: 13

  Min Bid: $50,000

  Final Price: $188,310

• Lot #14: 8/24/1931 Babe Ruth (NYY @ CHI) Career Home Run #602 Baseball Signed by Ruth, Lou Gehrig & Tony Lazzeri (Sourced from White Sox Fan Who Retrieved It!) – PSA/DNA & JSA LOAs

  

  # Bids: 11

  Min Bid: $15,000

  Final Price: Pass

• Lot #15: Epic Oct. 3, 1951 Bobby Thomson N.Y. Giants vs. Brooklyn Dodgers "Shot Heard 'Round the World" Game Used Cleats from Famous Homer to Win NL Pennant! – Family LOA from Giants Owner Horace Stoneham

  

  # Bids: 6

  Min Bid: $25,000

  Final Price: $97,999

• Lot #16: 1960 Brooks Robinson Signed (Twice) Baltimore Orioles Game Worn Road Jersey with Two Photomatches (First of 16 Straight Gold Glove Seasons!) – Sports Investors & PSA/DNA LOAs

  

  # Bids: 12

  Min Bid: $20,000

  Final Price: Pass

• Lot #17: 1960 Dick Groat National League Batting Champion Silver Award Bat (Also Won NL MVP & World Series that Season!) – Dick Groat LOA

  

  # Bids: 13

  Min Bid: $10,000

  Final Price: Pass

• Lot #18: 1973 Frank Robinson Signed Louisville Slugger Game Used Bat Photomatched to Two of His Topps Cards! – PSA/DNA GU 10, Beckett & PSA/DNA LOAs

  

  # Bids: 11

  Min Bid: $4,000

  Final Price: $24,274

• Lot #32: 1963 Topps #537 Pete Rose Rookie – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 11

  Min Bid: $2,500

  Final Price: $12,545

• Lot #33: 1964 Topps #125 Pete Rose (All-Star Rookie Cup) – PSA Mint 9 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 16

  Min Bid: $5,000

  Final Price: $22,796

• Lot #34: 1965 Topps #207 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Only Two Higher!)

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $2,500

  Final Price: $10,367

• Lot #35: 1966 Topps #30 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $1,500

  Final Price: $4,673

• Lot #36: 1967 Topps #430 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Only One Higher!)

  

  # Bids: 13

  Min Bid: $1,000

  Final Price: $7,361

• Lot #37: 1968 Topps #230 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $2,225

• Lot #38: 1969 Topps #120 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $1,000

  Final Price: $2,836

• Lot #39: 1969 Topps #424 Pete Rose All-Star – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 16

  Min Bid: $1,000

  Final Price: $5,530

• Lot #40: 1970 Topps #580 Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $7,500

  Final Price: $21,228

• Lot #41: 1970 Topps #458 Pete Rose All Star – PSA Mint 9 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $2,000

  Final Price: $7,540

• Lot #42: 1970 Topps #61 NL Batting Leaders (Rose/Clemente/Jones) – PSA Mint 9 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 6

  Min Bid: $500

  Final Price: $1,172

• Lot #43: 1971 Topps #100 Pete Rose - PSA Mint 9 (Only One Higher!)

  

  # Bids: 16

  Min Bid: $2,500

  Final Price: $26,896

• Lot #44: 1971 Topps Greatest Moments #15 Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8 (Four Higher)

  

  # Bids: 15

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $1,517

• Lot #45: 1972 Topps #559 Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 12

  Min Bid: $7,500

  Final Price: $37,610

• Lot #46: 1973 Topps #130 Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 19

  Min Bid: $1,500

  Final Price: $34,621

• Lot #47: 1973 Topps #202 NL Playoffs (Foster's Run Decides It) – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $1,000

  Final Price: $2,578

• Lot #48: 1974 Topps #300 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $775

• Lot #49: 1975 Topps #320 Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 13

  Min Bid: $1,500

  Final Price: $17,762

• Lot #50: 1976 Topps #240 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 14

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $2,022

• Lot #51: 1977 Topps #450 Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $2,500

  Final Price: $7,788

• Lot #52: 1978 Topps #20 Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $940

• Lot #53: 1979 Topps #650 Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 12

  Min Bid: $2,500

  Final Price: $9,424

• Lot #54: 1963 French Bauer Reds Milk Caps Pete Rose – PSA GD 2

  

  # Bids: 7

  Min Bid: $1,000

  Final Price: $2,836

• Lot #55: 1964 Topps Rookie All-Star Banquet #12 with Pete Rose ('63 Rookie AS Team) – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 12

  Min Bid: $500

  Final Price: $2,520

• Lot #56: 1967 Topps Punch-Outs Pete Rose – PSA EX 5 (Pop 2, Only Four Higher)

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $500

  Final Price: $1,420

• Lot #57: 1968 Jamesway Trucking Co. Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 12

  Min Bid: $500

  Final Price: $1,720

• Lot #58: 1968 Topps Plaks Checklist #2 (National League) – PSA VG 3

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $500

  Final Price: $2,291

• Lot #59: 1968-70 Partridge Meats Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT+ 8.5

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $715

• Lot #60: 1969 Topps 4-in-1 Pete Rose/Strange/Sutton/Uhlaender – PSA Mint 9 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 15

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $1,837

• Lot #61: 1970 Jack Gilligan Says "Go Big Red Machine" Johnny Bench / Pete Rose – PSA VG-EX 4 (Pop One, Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $500

  Final Price: $968

• Lot #62: 1971 Topps Tattoos Pete Rose (Preforated) – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 7

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $216

• Lot #63: 1972 Pro Star Promotions Pete Rose – PSA Gem Mint 10 (Pop 4)

  

  # Bids: 4

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $528

• Lot #64: 1972 Venezuelan Stamps #65 Pete Rose – PSA GD 2

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $715

• Lot #65: 1972 Venezuelan Stamps #187 Pete Rose – PSA VG 3

  

  # Bids: 18

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $2,052

• Lot #66: 1962-65 Jay Publishing Photos Pete Rose Type 2 (Portrait) – PSA EX 5

  

  # Bids: 4

  Min Bid: $175

  Final Price: $282

• Lot #67: 1962-65 Jay Publishing Photos Pete Rose Type 2 (Kneeling) – PSA EX 5

  

  # Bids: 6

  Min Bid: $175

  Final Price: $377

• Lot #68: 1964 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Picture Pack – PSA EX 5

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $175

  Final Price: $311

• Lot #69: 1963 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Picture Back – PSA VG-EX 4

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $175

  Final Price: $672

• Lot #70: 1965 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Picture Pack – PSA VG-EX 4

  

  # Bids: 6

  Min Bid: $175

  Final Price: $611

• Lot #71: 1963 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Postcard - PSA VG-EX 4

  

  # Bids: 12

  Min Bid: $175

  Final Price: $1,085

• Lot #72: 1964 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Postcards - PSA GD 2 (Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 6

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $196

• Lot #73: 1965 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Postcard – PSA EX 5

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $385

• Lot #74: 1966 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Team Issue Postcard – PSA VG-EX 4 (Pop 3, Only One Higher)

  

  # Bids: 7

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $216

• Lot #75: 1967 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Team Issue Postcard – PSA EX-MT 6 (Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $196

• Lot #76: 1968 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Team Issue Postcard – PSA EX-MT 6 (Pop 3, None Higher!)

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $468

• Lot #77: 1969 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Team Issue Postcard (Looking Front) – PSA NM-MT 8 (Only One Higher)

  

  # Bids: 4

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $241

• Lot #78: 1970 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Team Issue Postcard (Facing Front) – PSA NM 7

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $145

• Lot #79: 1971 Cincinnati Reds Pete Rose Team Issue Postcard – PSA NM-MT 8 (Only One Higher)

  

  # Bids: 1

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $180

• Lot #80: 1971 Rose & Bench Lincoln-Mercury Postcards Set of (10) Cards - All But (1) PSA NM 7 or Higher

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $364

• Lot #81: 1972 Rose & Bench Lincoln-Mercury Postcards Complete Set of (9) Cards – All but Two PSA NM 7 or Higher

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $401

• Lot #82: 1964 Kahn's Wieners Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $704

• Lot #83: 1965 Kahn's Wieners Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $1,139

• Lot #84: 1966 Kahn's Wieners #27 Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 7

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $1,034

• Lot #85: 1967 Kahn's Wieners Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Only One Higher!)

  

  # Bids: 13

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $1,139

• Lot #86: 1964 Topps Coins #82 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $640

• Lot #87: 1971 Topps Coins #101 Pete Rose – PSA MINT 9

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $425

• Lot #88: 1969 CITGO Coins Pete Rose (PSA Mint 9) and 1969 MLBPA Pins Pete Rose (PSA NM-MT 8)

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $200

  Final Price: $290

• Lot #89: 1964 Venezuela Topps #125 Pete Rose – PSA VG-EX 4 (Only Two Higher)

  

  # Bids: 20

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $3,259

• Lot #90: 1966 Venezuela Topps #30 Pete Rose – PSA EX-MT 6 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 4

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $715

• Lot #91: 1966 Venezuela Topps #59 Cincinnati Reds – PSA EX 5

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $475

• Lot #92: 1967 Venezuela Topps #270 Pete Rose – PSA EX 5 (Only Two Higher)

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $1,379

• Lot #93: 1968 Venezuela Topps #230 Pete Rose – PSA VG-EX 4 (Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 6

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $775

• Lot #94: 1965 MacGregor Pete Rose (Crouching w/ Glove) – PSA VG-EX 4 (Pop 2, Only One Higher)

  

  # Bids: 11

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $1,540

• Lot #95: 1966 MacGregor Pete Rose Signed & Inscribed – PSA PR 1, PSA/DNA Auth. (Only Signed Example in PSA Pop!)

  

  # Bids: 4

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $401

• Lot #96: 1969 MacGregor Pete Rose Portrait to Chest – PSA GD 2 (Pop 1, Only One Higher)

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $787

• Lot #97: 1973 MacGregor Pete Rose Advisory Staff Portrait – PSA VG-EX 4 (Pop 2, Only Four Higher)

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $401

• Lot #98: 1965 O-Pee-Chee #207 Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT+ 8.5 (Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 10

  Min Bid: $500

  Final Price: $2,291

• Lot #99: 1966 O-Pee-Chee #30 Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $1,034

• Lot #100: 1966 O-Pee-Chee #59 Reds Team - PSA NM-MT 8 & 1973 O-Pee-Chee #641 Reds Team - PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $196

• Lot #101: 1969 O-Pee-Chee #120 Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8 (Only Three Higher)

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $364

• Lot #102: 1969 Topps and O-Pee-Chee NL Batting Leaders (Pete Rose/M.Alou/F.Alou) Pair – PSA Mint 9 & NM-MT+ 8.5

  

  # Bids: 4

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $442

• Lot #103: 1970 O-Pee-Chee #458 Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $392

• Lot #104: 1970 O-Pee-Chee Pair of #61 NL Batting Leaders (Clemente/Rose) and #544 Reds Team – PSA EX 5 & PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 2

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $198

• Lot #105: 1971 O-Pee-Chee #100 Pete Rose – PSA NM-MT 8 (Only Two Higher!)

  

  # Bids: 12

  Min Bid: $400

  Final Price: $2,225

• Lot #106: 1971 O-Pee-Chee #357 Reds Team – PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $262

• Lot #107: 1973 O-Pee-Chee Pete Rose (PSA NM-MT 8), NL Playoffs (PSA EX-MT 6), and Cincinnati Reds Team Checklist (PSA VG-EX 4)

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $145

• Lot #108: 1974 O-Pee-Chee #300 Pete Rose – PSA EX-MT 6

  

  # Bids: 1

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $180

• Lot #109: 1974 O-Pee-Chee Trio of #201 Batting Leaders (Rose/Carew), #336 AS Left Fielders, and #559 Reds Team – All PSA NM-MT 8

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $392

• Lot #110: 1975 O-Pee-Chee #320 Pete Rose – PSA Mint 9 (Highest Graded!)

  

  # Bids: 7

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $866

• Lot #111: 1975 O-Pee-Chee #211 '73 MVPs (Rose/Jackson) and 1976 O-Pee-Chee '75 World Series Reds Champs – PSA NM-MT 8 & EX 5

  

  # Bids: 3

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $161

• Lot #112: 1975 O-Pee-Chee #531 Reds Team (Sparky Anderson Manager) – PSA MINT 9

  

  # Bids: 9

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $425

• Lot #113: 1976 O-Pee-Chee #104 Reds Team – PSA Mint 9 (None Higher)

  

  # Bids: 13

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $697

• Lot #114: 1976-79 O-Pee-Chee Lot of (5) Pete Rose Cards – Four PSA Mint 9, One PSA NM 7

  

  # Bids: 7

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $589

• Lot #115: 1965-68 Topps Lot of (4) Reds Team Cards – All PSA Mint 9

  

  # Bids: 7

  Min Bid: $150

  Final Price: $475

• Lot #116: 1970-73 Topps Lot of (4) Reds Team Cards – All PSA Mint 9

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $250

  Final Price: $866

• Lot #117: 1974-1976 Lot of (5) Topps & Topps Mini Reds Team Cards – Two PSA Gem Mint 10, Three PSA Mint 9

  

  # Bids: 5

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $853

• Lot #118: 1978 Topps #526 Reds Team – PSA Mint 9

  

  # Bids: 8

  Min Bid: $300

  Final Price: $2,022

• Lot #119: 1977 Topps #287 Reds Team – PSA Gem Mint 10

  

  # Bids: 4

  Min Bid: $100

  Final Price: $262